Skip to main content
Mandi Law Group

§Employer Compliance Guide

Does a New York Employer Have to Use E-Verify?

Last updated:

Quick answer

Not by default: E-Verify is voluntary for many employers, but it is required for federal contractors whose contracts carry the FAR E-Verify clause, and some state or local contracts may require it. Any employer may enroll voluntarily, but once enrolled it must verify every new hire and follow every rule, including the notice and waiting-period steps when an employee receives a Tentative Nonconfirmation (TNC). Mandi Law Group handles these cases from its Latham, NY office — the firm's only office, minutes from the USCIS Albany Field Office and open to walk-ins Monday to Friday, 9:00 to 18:00 ET — and by phone or video anywhere in New York. Call (518) 698-0347.

Complete guide to E-Verify requirements, enrollment, proper use, TNC resolution, and avoiding penalties. It is meant for federal contractors and any employer that uses E-Verify.

01Overview

What is E-Verify?

E-Verify is a free, web-based system operated by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) in partnership with the Social Security Administration (SSA). It allows employers to electronically verify employment eligibility of newly hired employees by comparing Form I-9 information to government records.

How It Works

  1. 1. Employee completes Form I-9
  2. 2. Employer enters I-9 info into E-Verify
  3. 3. System checks SSA and DHS databases
  4. 4. Result returned online: authorized or TNC
  5. 5. Employee resolves TNC if needed

Key Facts

  • • Free government service
  • • Supplements (doesn't replace) Form I-9
  • • Case created within 3 business days of hire
  • • Photo matching tool for certain documents (see the E-Verify MOU)

§People also ask

What happens after a Tentative Nonconfirmation (TNC)?

The employer must promptly notify the employee in private and provide the Further Action Notice and referral letter. The employee then has 8 federal government work days to contact SSA or DHS. The employer may not take adverse action because of the employee's perceived work authorization status while the case is being processed, unless the employer learns the employee is not work authorized.

Can E-Verify be run before Form I-9 is complete?

No. Form I-9 must be completed first. The employee completes Section 1 on or before the first day of work, and the employer completes Section 2 within 3 business days of hire. E-Verify is run after I-9 is complete, with the case created within 3 business days of hire.

What is the penalty for misusing E-Verify?

Program violations, such as late case creation, selective use, or screening applicants before hire, can lead to suspension from E-Verify. Discrimination violations, such as requesting specific documents or treating employees differently by national origin, can draw a DOJ investigation, civil penalties, and back pay (8 U.S.C. 1324b).

02Who is covered

Who Must Use E-Verify?

  1. Federal Contractors (FAR E-Verify Clause)

    Mandatory for federal contractors and subcontractors with contracts containing the FAR E-Verify clause (FAR 52.222-54). FAR 22.1803 says which contracts get the clause.

    Requirements:

    • • Contract value over $150,000 (FAR 22.1803, text checked November 8, 2026)
    • • Not a contract of less than 120 days
    • • Not work performed only outside the United States
    • • Not a contract only for commercially available off-the-shelf (COTS) items
    • • Contractors not yet enrolled must enroll within 30 days of award. Once using E-Verify, the contractor checks every new hire working in the United States within 3 business days after hire, whether or not the person works on the contract (FAR 52.222-54(b))
    • • Employees assigned to the contract are checked within 90 days after enrollment or award, or within 30 days of assignment, whichever is later
    • • Colleges and universities, state and local governments, and tribal governments may choose to check only employees assigned to the contract (FAR 52.222-54(b)(3))
  2. State-Specific Requirements

    Some states and local governments require E-Verify for certain employers or contracts. Check the rules and contract terms that apply to your business in New York.

    Check with your legal counsel about state-specific E-Verify requirements, especially if you do business with state or local government entities.

  3. Voluntary Enrollment

    Even if not required, employers may voluntarily enroll in E-Verify to ensure workforce compliance and demonstrate good faith hiring practices.

    Benefits

    • • Reduced risk of hiring unauthorized workers
    • • May help show good-faith compliance
    • • Streamlined verification process

    Considerations

    • • Must follow all E-Verify rules
    • • Cannot use selectively (must verify all new hires)
    • • Training required for HR staff

03How it works

How E-Verify Works (Step-by-Step)

  1. Complete Form I-9 First

    Employee completes Section 1 of I-9 on or before first day of work. Employer examines documents and completes Section 2 within 3 business days. E-Verify is run AFTER I-9 is completed, not instead of.

  2. Create E-Verify Case

    Within 3 business days after hire, once Form I-9 is complete, enter employee information from I-9 into E-Verify system. Enter exactly as it appears on documents - typos cause TNCs.

  3. Receive Initial Result

    System returns result within seconds: (1) Employment Authorized - case closed, or (2) Tentative Nonconfirmation (TNC) - employee must take action, or (3) DHS Verification in Process - wait for further instructions.

  4. Notify Employee of TNC (if applicable)

    If you receive a TNC, promptly notify the employee in private and give the employee the Further Action Notice and referral letter. The employee decides whether to contest. Do not take adverse action based on the employee's perceived work authorization status while the case is processed (E-Verify MOU).

  5. Employee Resolves TNC (if applicable)

    The employee has 8 federal government work days to contact SSA or DHS. Employee provides evidence to correct records. Employer refers case in E-Verify.

  6. Receive Final Result

    After employee contacts agency: (1) Employment Authorized - case closed, or (2) Final Nonconfirmation - employee not work-authorized. You may terminate employment based on final nonconfirmation.

04TNCs

Tentative Nonconfirmations (TNCs)

What Causes TNCs?

SSA TNCs

  • • Name doesn't match SSN records
  • • Citizenship status issue in SSA database
  • • Typographical error in data entry
  • • Recent name change (marriage/divorce)

DHS TNCs

  • • Work authorization expired
  • • Immigration status not current in system
  • • USCIS number doesn't match
  • • Photo non-match on document

Employer Obligations When TNC Received

  • Promptly notify the employee in private
  • Provide Further Action Notice to employee
  • Allow employee to review case details
  • Do not terminate or take adverse action during the resolution period (unless you learn the employee is not work authorized)
  • CANNOT influence employee's decision to contest
  • Document all steps taken
  • Give the employee 8 federal government work days to contact SSA or DHS

05Penalties

Penalties for Non-Compliance

E-Verify Violations

  • • Using E-Verify before completing I-9
  • • Creating a case more than 3 business days after hire
  • • Not providing TNC notice to employee
  • • Terminating employee during TNC period
  • • Using E-Verify selectively (only some hires)
  • • Screening job applicants before hire

Consequences:

Suspension or termination from the E-Verify program, and possible discrimination charges

Discrimination Violations

  • • Requesting specific documents
  • • Rejecting valid documents
  • • Only verifying foreign-appearing employees
  • • Delaying work start for E-Verify
  • • Treating employees differently during TNC
  • • Retaliating against employees who complain

Consequences:

A DOJ investigation. Remedies under 8 U.S.C. 1324b can include civil penalties, back pay, and hiring.

06Best practices

E-Verify Best Practices

  • Train All Users

    Complete E-Verify tutorial, stay updated on policy changes, designate E-Verify coordinators

  • Complete I-9 First

    Never use E-Verify before I-9 is completed. This is a violation and can lead to program suspension

  • Timely Case Creation

    Create E-Verify case within 3 business days of hire date, not before employee starts work

  • Accurate Data Entry

    Enter information exactly as it appears on documents. Double-check before submitting to avoid TNCs

  • Consistent Application

    Verify ALL new hires - cannot pick and choose based on appearance, name, or accent

  • Proper TNC Handling

    Notify employee promptly, provide Further Action Notice, allow the full 8 federal government work days

  • Maintain Records

    Keep E-Verify case printouts with I-9 forms. The I-9 itself must be kept 3 years after hire or 1 year after employment ends, whichever is later (8 CFR 274a.2(b)(2)(i)(A))

  • Protect Privacy

    Do not share E-Verify results with unauthorized persons. Keep TNC information confidential

  • Display Notices

    Post required notices: E-Verify participation poster, anti-discrimination notice, Right to Work notice

07What changed recently

What Changed Recently

Since August 1, 2023, DHS has allowed certain employers to use an alternative procedure to examine Form I-9 documents remotely instead of in person. USCIS says employers who use it must check the box on the form. See USCIS I-9 Central for who qualifies and what the procedure requires. E-Verify also uses photo matching for certain documents, such as U.S. passports and passport cards, and some DHS-issued cards. Confirm you are working from the current edition of Form I-9, posted at uscis.gov/i-9, before your next hire. As of the USCIS page we checked on November 8, 2026, the current Form I-9 has an edition date of 01/20/25 and an expiration date of 05/31/2027. USCIS also still accepts the 08/01/23 edition that shows the 05/31/2027 expiration date.

08When this needs a lawyer

Does This Actually Need a Lawyer?

Not always. Routine enrollment, everyday data entry, and a straightforward TNC that an employee resolves on their own timeline are administrative — HR staff who have completed the free E-Verify tutorial may be able to handle them without counsel.

Call an employment immigration attorney when: your company receives a Notice of Inspection or an ICE/HSI I-9 audit; you are unsure whether the FAR E-Verify clause applies to a specific federal or state contract; a TNC raises a citizenship-status question you do not know how to explain to the employee without risking a discrimination claim; or you are setting up E-Verify company-wide for the first time and want the procedure reviewed before you rely on it across every hire.

09Questions employers ask

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a New York employer have to use E-Verify?
Not by default. E-Verify is voluntary for many employers. It is required for federal contractors and subcontractors whose contracts carry the FAR E-Verify clause (FAR 52.222-54). FAR 22.1803 says which contracts get the clause: it has a contract-value threshold (over $150,000 in the FAR text we checked on November 8, 2026) and exceptions, such as contracts under 120 days and work done only outside the United States. Some state or local contracts may also require E-Verify, so check your contract terms. Employers who are not required to enroll may still do so voluntarily, but once enrolled they must follow every E-Verify rule for all new hires. It cannot be used selectively.
What happens after a Tentative Nonconfirmation (TNC)?
The E-Verify MOU (the agreement employers sign) says the employer must promptly notify the employee in private and give the employee the Further Action Notice and referral letter. The employee then has 8 federal government work days to contact SSA or DHS. While SSA or DHS is processing the case, the employer may not take adverse action against the employee because of the employee's perceived work authorization status, unless the employer learns the employee is not work authorized. If the case ends in a Final Nonconfirmation, the employer may then end employment based on that result. Read the current MOU and E-Verify instructions for the exact steps.
Can E-Verify be run before Form I-9 is complete?
No. Form I-9 comes first. The employee completes Section 1 on or before the first day of work, and the employer completes Section 2 within 3 business days of hire (8 CFR 274a.2(b)(1)(ii)). Under the E-Verify MOU, the employer creates the E-Verify case within 3 business days after the hire, after both sections of Form I-9 are complete and the job offer has been accepted.
What is the penalty for misusing E-Verify?
There are two separate areas of risk. E-Verify program violations, such as late case creation, selective use, screening applicants before hire, or failing to give the TNC notice, can lead the program to suspend or end an employer's participation. Discrimination violations, such as asking for specific documents, rejecting valid ones, or treating employees differently because of national origin or citizenship status, can lead to a Department of Justice investigation. Remedies under 8 U.S.C. 1324b can include civil penalties and back pay. A single mistake can touch both areas.

11Where we serve

Need E-Verify Compliance Help?

Our immigration compliance attorneys serve NY employers

§Official sources

Official Sources and Documents to Have Ready

Before you enroll or respond to a notice, gather your signed E-Verify MOU, the Form I-9 for each employee, any federal contract that includes the E-Verify clause, and your E-Verify case records.

§Talk to us

Stay Compliant with E-Verify

E-Verify compliance is complex. Our immigration attorneys help employers enroll, implement proper procedures, train staff, and avoid violations.