Skip to main content
Mandi Law Group

§I-9 Compliance Lawyer

I-9 Compliance Lawyer in New York — Audit Readiness

Quick answer

Federal law under INA § 274A requires every U.S. employer to verify identity and employment authorization on Form I-9 within three business days of each employee's hire date. Employers must retain I-9 forms for three years after hire or one year after separation, whichever is later, and must respond within three business days when served an ICE Notice of Inspection. Mandi Law Group handles these cases from its Latham, NY office — the firm's only office, minutes from the USCIS Albany Field Office and open to walk-ins Monday to Friday, 9:00 to 18:00 ET — and by phone or video anywhere in New York.

Mandi Law Group helps New York employers review I-9 systems, clean up recordkeeping problems, and prepare for government review before a small problem grows.

Once Immigration and Customs Enforcement serves a Notice of Inspection, an employer generally has three business days to produce its I-9 records. That is not enough time to find the files, fix what is wrong, and take advice. The work that matters happens before the notice arrives.

Helping New York City and statewide employers with I-9 review, process cleanup, and audit response planning.

  • Employer compliance focus
  • Audit-readiness support
  • Notice of Inspection response

Ask an immigration lawyer

Confidential.

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not send confidential information until a written engagement letter is signed.

Confidential. Immigration matters only.

ATTORNEY ADVERTISING. This website is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

01What to know

What an I-9 compliance lawyer actually does for a New York employer

Employers usually call at one of three moments: an HR manager has just discovered that forms are missing or filled in wrong, a new owner or investor wants the file checked before closing, or a Notice of Inspection has arrived and the three-business-day clock is already running. Each calls for a different first step. A Notice of Inspection should not be handled like a routine cleanup.

Most violations we find are technical rather than knowing: missing dates, the wrong box checked in Section 1, reverification done when it was not required, or records destroyed before the retention period ran. Many errors can be corrected the right way, and it is best to find them before the government does.

02Services

I-9 compliance lawyer support for employers

  • Internal I-9 audits and gap identification before agency review
  • Risk review for missing forms, reverification errors, and inconsistent practices
  • Notice of Inspection response planning and document organization
  • Training and workflow recommendations for HR and hiring managers
  • E-Verify alignment with broader I-9 compliance systems
  • Notice of Intent to Fine review and hearing requests, which must be made within 30 days of service (8 CFR 274a.9)

03Why this firm

What an I-9 review actually covers

Every form read, not sampled
We go through the forms themselves, the retention and purge schedule, the reverification triggers, and how the company onboards remote hires. Each of those is a common source of penalties and each is fixable in advance.
Correction done the right way
There is a correct way to fix an I-9 error and several ways that make it worse. USCIS says employers should not conceal changes to a form, and doing so may lead to more liability. Corrections are made in the open, initialed and dated, so the record shows what happened and when.
Penalties can add up with the headcount
Civil penalties for paperwork violations are set for each individual with a violation (8 CFR 274a.10(b)(2)), so the same mistake repeated on many forms adds up. Finding a pattern early lets the employer correct it properly.
A plan for the day the notice arrives
You will know in advance who receives the Notice of Inspection, who calls counsel, what gets produced, and what does not get touched. A plan helps the company respond in an orderly way and avoid changing records under pressure.

04Questions clients ask

I-9 Compliance Lawyer in New York — Audit Readiness FAQs

When should an employer contact an I-9 compliance lawyer?

An employer should contact counsel before a problem escalates, especially if forms are missing, reverification is inconsistent, documents were handled incorrectly, or a Notice of Inspection may be coming.

Can an I-9 compliance lawyer help before ICE contacts the company?

Yes. A preventive review lets the employer find process issues, organize records, and reduce risk before any formal review begins.

Can we correct our own I-9 errors before anyone inspects them?

Often yes. USCIS explains that an employer may correct errors in Section 2 or Supplement B. If the error is in Section 1, the employee should correct it. To correct a form, draw a line through the wrong information, enter the correct information, and initial and date the change. For larger errors, a new form can be completed and attached to the old one. Put a note in the file explaining why. Do not conceal changes, and do not backdate. If a form is missing altogether, talk with counsel about how to complete it before you do anything else.

What happens if we already received a Notice of Inspection?

Call before you hand anything over. The rule gives the employer at least three business days' notice before an inspection (8 CFR 274a.2(b)(2)(ii)). Do not correct forms after the notice arrives without advice, and do not hand over records outside what the notice asks for.

How long must an employer keep Form I-9?

An employer must keep each Form I-9 for three years after the date of hire or one year after employment ends, whichever is later (8 CFR 274a.2(b)(2)(i)(A)). Forms must be available if authorized officials ask to inspect them.

Is this legal advice?

No. The information here is general and cannot replace legal advice on a specific employer's records, timeline, or audit position.

What to Expect From a Confidential Consultation

Reaching out doesn't commit you to anything. Here is exactly what happens when you contact Mandi Law Group.

  1. Step 1: Call or send the form

    Reach out by phone or through our contact form. Your first conversation is confidential, with no obligation to hire us.

  2. Step 2: Case review with an attorney

    Bring your documents and any notices you've received. We review your situation and explain your options in plain language.

  3. Step 3: We start work on your case

    Once you decide to move forward and sign a retainer agreement, we begin working on your case.

§Talk to us

Need an I-9 cleanup or audit-readiness review?

Book a consultation if your company needs record review, internal process help, or a response plan for verification-related risk.

Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes and not legal advice. Immigration law is fact specific and outcome dependent. Consult a licensed attorney about your individual situation. We work to keep this information accurate and up to date, but immigration law changes often and this content may contain errors or be out of date. Always check the official government source, such as uscis.gov, justice.gov/eoir or travel.state.gov, before you act.